WHICH SCIENCE IS AT WAR WITH WHICH FAITH?
Interpretations of Biblical Creation Account(s) and Various Types of Science By Bruce Herdrich
The predominant message in today’s controlled-media and imposed culture is that “Faith is at War with Science”. Two essential questions must be asked to bring clarity to this statement and discern how truthful it is.
1. Which Faith is in question here? (What is the faith in?)
2. Which type, or form of Science is involved in this war?
Along with this, we must clearly define what is meant by faith and what is meant by science.
Now Faith is assurance of things hoped for, a conviction of things not seen. Hebrews 11:1 American Standard Version.
This states, it is possible that some things that cannot be seen, are still worthy of believing in, (having faith that they exist). For instance, before powerful telescopes were made, it would be correct to believe that there were other stars existing in space that had not yet been seen. The telescopes later showed that this faith in the unseen was warranted.
Different forms of faith can exist, as determined by what the object of the faith is, how trustworthy it is, and what it promises to the faithful. Faith can be in almost anything, as long as it is trusted by someone. One can even have faith in science or in a particular theory of science, trusting in it to deliver truth or possible relief from certain problems. At times, this faith has proven worthy in certain cases, and in other cases has disappointed or has not yet been confirmed or realized.
There can be various faiths in the Bible, according to the various forms of Bible interpretations held by its believers. Some people have faith in a single creation account told straight-forwardly in a God centered perspective and then also in an earth-centered perspective. Others believe in two sequential creation accounts involving deep time separating them. Some believe in one or two accounts which must be re-interpreted using ancient human literature and legends. Hopefully, any Bible believer would try to have faith in God’s interpretation of God’s Word, rather than man’s interpretation of God’s Word.
Bible believers are often asked to yield their faith in a particular interpretation of Scripture, to other considerations outside scripture, such as “SCIENCE”, as if there has always been only one perfectly true form of Science ever practiced by humans in complete unanimity. But is this a true view of the practice of science? What version of “science” is even agreed upon by all scientists?
Just as there are many interpretations of the Bible, are there not also different types of science and various versions of scientific ideas and theories?
It is essential to acknowledge the two types of science, and to recognize the true nature of their endeavors.
What is science?
One type of science is operational science which involves repeated observations of repeatable events which can be consistently replicated with the same initial conditions and boundary conditions. This is the essence of the scientific method. If the same result is consistently seen, it might be related to a condition which is consistently present, and therefore could be its cause.
Science is knowledge acquired by observing the same consistent results caused from the same duplicated conditions existing in each of the repeated observations, thus establishing a cause-and-effect relationship.
The other type of science is historical science (also known as forensic science), which observes non-repeatable events or its after-math, in which the initial conditions and boundary conditions cannot be replicated exactly. These events can be weather storms or earthquakes which always have varying results from one event to the next. These events also include human activities such as sporting games and criminal actions. The situations’ conditions and human abilities and motives can never be assuredly duplicated in a replication. Only the left-over remnants can be examined for clues, like solving a crime.
This is the situation with any concept of origins of the universe and the initiation of the first generation of each life form. It is not a repeatable event that can be replicated in a laboratory or in the field. Urey-Miller’s experiment is nowhere close to an accurate simulation and its results nowhere close to creating life from non-life. Operational science can’t be accurately applied to any origins experiments. All existing kinds of animals, never reproduce a new different kind of animal, as repeatedly seen by every birth of each life form.
Evolution theory, a purely naturalistic theory of origins of the universe and life origins, claims that everything came into existence for the first time by the same natural processes that we see today. Therefore, it could theoretically be examined in terms of operational science. But if it has any chance of being true, then those natural processes that caused the originations, could never have violated any of the natural laws that govern those natural processes.
The operational science of actual direct repeatable consistent observations, shows that it is impossible for mere natural processes to naturally make matter and energy from nothing, a violation of the natural law of conservation of mass and energy. And it’s impossible for natural processes to naturally make life from anything not already alive, in violation of the natural law of Biogenesis.
It is impossible for supposed simple life to naturally evolve into highly functional and complex life in violation of the natural 2nd law of thermodynamics. New specified information for new functionality cannot be generated naturally without a mind thinking it up.
So scientifically speaking, origins by naturalistic evolution could not have happened. Therefore Bible believers should not be asked to yield their interpretation of Scripture, to the so-called science of evolution. Rather they should be asked if a straight-forward interpretation of Scripture is consistent with actual observations of nature, many of which appear to demand a supernatural origination.
Finding God’s Interpretation of God’s Word, instead of man’s interpretation of His Word:
Regarding any particular interpretation of the Bible, we should always ask “who is honored and glorified by that interpretation?” God’s Word says that God is most glorious, and that God is worthy of all honor. Therefore, God’s interpretation of God’s Word must glorify God and not glorify man.
If an interpretation glorifies God, it is more likely to be God’s interpretation instead of man’s interpretation. And if it is God’s interpretation, is not it also more likely to be a true interpretation? If it is also true, then God is correct and right, which is consistent with God being glorious.
But if God is wrong, then why even believe in God’s Word? Do you really want to believe in something that is not true or in a God that is wrong? That is no god at all. The following chart with some examples, demonstrates this idea of a true Godly interpretation of God’s Word.
= God’s Interpretation of God’s Word
= Man’s Interpretation of God’s Word
In example X , a Biblical interpretation considers its proposition as false, thus placing it as X in the lower half of the plot, while man’s interpretation considers it to be true, placing it as X in the upper half of the plot.
God’s interpretation of God’s Word is His Scripture explaining itself in light of related passages from the same Scripture. Clear passages bring to light other passages that are less clear, supporting each other without contradiction.
Can we be as faithful in believing God’s interpretation of God’s Word, as God’s Word has been faithful in describing the reality of the universe God created?
Regarding the so-called War between Science and Faith in the Bible’s Creation account:
It appears that theologian John Walton believes that “the war is over”, when he applied the literature of ancient near-eastern human legends to the interpretation of the Genesis account, as this harmonizes it with the deep time required by the ‘science’ of evolution. However, if that science is false, then the harmonized interpretation of the Bible is also false.
Instead, I believe that there never was any war between the Bible and true science, as a straight-forward interpretation of the Bible consistently agrees with the reality of God’s universe as revealed by actual direct scientific observations that are not just mere theories.
So which Faith is in conflict with which Science?
A faith in God’s true interpretation of God’s Word is not in conflict with true observations of God’s actual creation of nature (the universe).
Rather, a human interpretation of God’s Word could conflict with the real scientific observations of the real world.
Also a faith in a false theory of evolutionary ‘science’ does conflict with the reality of direct scientific observations, as well as the truth of the Bible.
This article is in response to John Walton’s lecture: Origins Today Genesis through Ancient Eyes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fR82a-iueWw